Shocking Breakthrough: Secret Photos Unveil Truth Behind Major Amy Bradley Disappearance Mystery

So, imagine settling in to binge Netflix’s Amy Bradley Is Missing, only to stumble upon a secret stash of photos lurking in the shadows—photos that weren’t part of the documentary but might just turn the whole “Amy is still alive” theory upside down. Amy vanished from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship back in ’98, spawning countless theories about her fate. One of the spookiest? That she was kidnapped and forced into human trafficking—a claim backed by a set of mysterious pictures discovered years later on a Caribbean-based sex worker website, showing a woman who looks eerily like Amy. The FBI even took a deep dive, forensic analysis and all, suggesting those photos could indeed be her. But hold on—enter the internet sleuths on Reddit, who unearthed additional images revealing details that don’t add up, like the absence of Amy’s distinctive Tasmanian Devil tattoo. Could these overlooked snapshots finally put this haunting theory to rest? Or is it just another twist in a decades-old mystery that refuses to die? Dive in and see why some fans think they’ve cracked the code, while others remain unconvinced. LEARN MORE

Viewers of the Amy Bradley documentary have come across a secret extra set of photos not included in the Netflix doc which they reckon debunks a major theory that she is still alive.

Amy disappeared off a Royal Caribbean cruise ship in 1998 and remains missing to this day, with Netflix’s AMY BRADLEY IS MISSING covering many of the major theories surrounding her disappearance.

One of the most popular is that she was somehow kidnapped off the cruise ship and sold into human trafficking, supported by a set of photos found in 2005, seven years after she disappeared.

Found on a sex worker website based out of the Caribbean, the woman in the photos shares a striking similarity to Amy.

The FBI investigated the photos thoroughly, with a forensic analysis confirming the photo very possibly could be her.

The photo showed up on a sex worker website and looks shockingly similar to Amy (Netflix)

This was discussed at length in the Netflix documentary, including the family’s hope it would lead to answers.

Even though some fans have done an image comparison which makes it seem impossible for the woman in the photo to not be her, a discovery on Reddit appears to have debunked the popular theory.

The images appear to be of the same woman, shot from the same angle, in the same bedroom, however they are a tad more NSFW than the ones that have been widely circulated.

Among these images is one which we will show below that shows her shoulder which fans say prove it isn’t her.

The photo was discovered by internet sleuths (Reddit)

One viewer of the doc took to Reddit to describe their dislike for one of the interviewees, a cruise ‘expert’.

In the replies to this one comment someone shared a link to the set of hidden photos, saying: “Here is the website, you can see from the other pictures it is clearly not Amy.”

Another comment said: “Oh wow the one photo where her back left shoulder is very clearly visible does not show a Tasmanian Devil tattoo which I thought they said she had there. Interesting that they left that photo out of the documentary.”

In the FBI’s description of Amy on its Missing Person’s site they still maintain she has ‘a Tasmanian Devil spinning a basketball on her shoulder’.

Amy Bradley went missing 27 years ago (Netflix)

The photos, which we cannot share or link to due to their sensitive nature, show her in various positions and seem to confirm that this is not present.

Another comment said: “Amy Bradley has a Tasmanian Devil tattoo there supposedly. This woman clearly doesn’t.

“I mean her FULL shoulder blade is not visible, but I’d feel like from the angle shown in the photo, you’d at least see part of it. The fact that you don’t has me convinced that this woman is not her.”

While it is not fully inconclusive it does put a major dampener on the theory.

AMY BRADLEY IS MISSING is available to watch on Netflix now.